Letter to the editor: torture

Every morning, I pick up the paper from my driveway. I like having the morning paper and my coffee while it is dark outside.

Yesterday, the paper published a letter from someone who thinks the United States should torture people.

I wrote a response, which was published this morning. This is what it says:

Regarding the Dec. 11 letter “ Don’t neuter CIA”: The letter-writer declared that “this is what a spy agency should be doing.”

If the writer, after looking at his letter in print, had chosen to look at the facing page, he would have seen the reprint of a Charlotte Observer editorial (“So much better than this”) that itemized the CIA practices detailed in the Senate report. Among them were “threatening to rape a detainee’s mother in front of the detainee,” “mock executions,” “Russian roulette,” “subjecting detainees with broken feet … to stress positions” and much more.

All of these practices would be perfectly acceptable if, say, North Korea’s spy agency had Americans in detention. Unless his letter was simply foolish bluster, this is surely what the writer meant.



Comments are closed.